Register

Login

Vet Times logo
+
  • View all news
  • Vets news
  • Vet Nursing news
  • Business news
  • + More
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Crossword
  • View all clinical
  • Small animal
  • Livestock
  • Equine
  • Exotics
  • All Jobs
  • Your ideal job
  • Post a job
  • Career Advice
  • Students
About
Contact Us
For Advertisers
NewsClinicalJobs
Vet Times logo

Vets

All Vets newsSmall animalLivestockEquineExoticWork and well-beingOpinion

Vet Nursing

All Vet Nursing newsSmall animalLivestockEquineExoticWork and well-beingOpinion

Business

All Business newsHuman resourcesBig 6SustainabilityFinanceDigitalPractice profilesPractice developments

+ More

VideosPodcastsDigital EditionCrossword

The latest veterinary news, delivered straight to your inbox.

Choose which topics you want to hear about and how often.

Vet Times logo 2

About

The team

Advertise with us

Recruitment

Contact us

Vet Times logo 2

Vets

All Vets news

Small animal

Livestock

Equine

Exotic

Work and well-being

Opinion

Vet Nursing

All Vet Nursing news

Small animal

Livestock

Equine

Exotic

Work and well-being

Opinion

Business

All Business news

Human resources

Big 6

Sustainability

Finance

Digital

Practice profiles

Practice developments

Clinical

All Clinical content

Small animal

Livestock

Equine

Exotics

Jobs

All Jobs content

All Jobs

Your ideal job

Post a job

Career Advice

Students

More

All More content

Videos

Podcasts

Digital Edition

Crossword


Terms and conditions

Complaints policy

Cookie policy

Privacy policy

fb-iconinsta-iconlinkedin-icontwitter-iconyoutube-icon

© Veterinary Business Development Ltd 2025

IPSO_regulated

18 Oct 2023

Senior vet warns of ‘significant problems’ with XL bully ban plan

A committee of MPs has heard concerns that Government plans to define and outlaw the breed by the end of the year will present major challenges for the veterinary and charitable sectors.

author_img

Allister Webb

Job Title



Senior vet warns of ‘significant problems’ with XL bully ban plan

Image © otsphoto / Adobe Stock

Leading veterinary and welfare sector figures have warned “significant problems” are likely in implementing and enforcing a ban on XL bully-type dogs.

The Government last month pledged to define and ban the breed by the end of the year, following a series of high-profile, and often fatal, attacks linked to the type.

But an emergency select committee session in Westminster today (18 October) heard wide-ranging concerns about the basis for a ban and how it might be introduced.

‘Mountain to climb’

David Martin, IVC Evidensia’s group animal welfare advisor, said potential requirements – such as large-scale neutering of affected dogs – would represent a “mountain” to climb for a profession that is already under pressure.

He highlighted difficulties in defining the breed itself, a lack of sufficiently robust data and practice capacity limitations as just some of the issues that need to be addressed.

Asked if he felt it was impossible to legislate for a ban, Dr Martin said: “I think we are going to have some significant problems.”

Meanwhile, the head of the RSPCA’s companion animals team, Sam Gaines, revealed her organisation had left the breed confirmation working group set up by Defra because it was so concerned about the approach being taken to the issue.

Abandoned dogs

She argued that the data being used to justify the Government’s policy was not sound and that a ban could lead to more XL-type dogs being abandoned.

But Lawrence Newport, co-founder of the Campaign for Evidence-based Regulation of Dangerous Dogs, argued the Government’s data justification was sound, and material from sources such as police records was the best currently available.

The session, which was held as part of the EFRA select committee’s wider inquiry on issues relating to pet welfare and abuse, was also told that a debate on two rival petitions related to the ban proposal is likely to take place next month.

Almost 590,000 people have signed a petition opposing a ban, while a counter-campaign supporting the plan has been backed by more than 28,000 signatures.

Full report in next week’s Vet Times.