‌

Register

Login

Vet Times logo
+
  • View all news
  • Vets news
  • Vet Nursing news
  • Business news
  • + More
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
  • View all clinical
  • Small animal
  • Livestock
  • Equine
  • Exotics
  • Vet Times jobs home
  • All Jobs
  • Your ideal job
  • Post a job
  • Career Advice
  • Students
About
Contact Us
For Advertisers
NewsClinicalJobs
Vet Times logo

Vets

All Vets newsSmall animalLivestockEquineExoticWork and well-beingOpinion

Vet Nursing

All Vet Nursing newsSmall animalLivestockEquineExoticWork and well-beingOpinion

Business

All Business newsHuman resourcesBig 6SustainabilityFinanceDigitalPractice profilesPractice developments

+ More

VideosPodcastsDigital Edition

The latest veterinary news, delivered straight to your inbox.

Choose which topics you want to hear about and how often.

Vet Times logo 2

About

The team

Advertise with us

Recruitment

Contact us

Vet Times logo 2

Vets

All Vets news

Small animal

Livestock

Equine

Exotic

Work and well-being

Opinion

Vet Nursing

All Vet Nursing news

Small animal

Livestock

Equine

Exotic

Work and well-being

Opinion

Business

All Business news

Human resources

Big 6

Sustainability

Finance

Digital

Practice profiles

Practice developments

Clinical

All Clinical content

Small animal

Livestock

Equine

Exotics

Jobs

All Jobs content

All Jobs

Your ideal job

Post a job

Career Advice

Students

More

All More content

Videos

Podcasts

Digital Edition


Terms and conditions

Complaints policy

Cookie policy

Privacy policy

fb-iconinsta-iconlinkedin-icontwitter-iconyoutube-icon

© Veterinary Business Development Ltd 2025

IPSO_regulated

25 Apr 2024

XL bully ban legal challenge gets go-ahead

A judge has given the green light for campaigners to challenge the Government’s decision to outlaw the controversial dog type.

author_img

Vet Times

Job Title



XL bully ban legal challenge gets go-ahead

Image © Jack / Adobe Stock

Campaigners against the ban on XL bully dogs in England and Wales have won the latest stage of their court battle on the issue.

A judge has granted permission for a legal challenge against the legislation to proceed to trial after ruling that it made an “arguable” case in certain areas.

A further hearing will now take place at a later date and Defra officials have stressed owners must still comply with the conditions of the ban.

But the Don’t Ban Me, Licence Me group, which brought the action, said it was “elated” at the latest ruling, which followed a hearing in London yesterday (24 April).

Controversial ban

Since February, it has been illegal to own a non-exempted XL bully in England and Wales. Similar measures are currently being introduced in Scotland, while plans for restrictions in Northern Ireland were announced last month.

Defra insists that XL bullies have been “disproportionately involved” in an increasing trend of dog attacks over recent years, including cases that have led to fatalities.

Although it would not comment directly on the current proceedings, a spokesperson said the department “firmly” believed its action was needed to protect the public.

He added: “We have delivered our pledge to bring in this important measure to protect public safety, and we expect all XL bully owners to comply with the strict conditions.”

Government failings

But the court was told the Government had failed to carry out “proper research” on the types of dogs involved in attacks.

In written arguments, Cathryn McGahey KC, for the campaigners, said the department had “no material on which to base a rational decision that dogs involved in recent attacks were disproportionately of XL bully type”, PA Media reported.

She also argued that requirements for dogs to be muzzled and kept on a lead in public would not stop attacks as most occur on private property.

She also criticised what she described as the “unlawful vagueness” of the Government’s breed standard, which she argued meant owners could not be sure whether their dog was of the banned type.

‌
‌
‌